blog

Why a smell can bring back a memory faster than anything else

Why a smell can bring back a memory faster than anything else

You walk past a bakery, or open a cupboard at a relative's house, and for a second you are somewhere else entirely, usually somewhere you haven't thought about in twenty years. The feeling tends to arrive well before you have worked out what the smell actually is, and no other sense does this quite as reliably. Psychologists sometimes call it the Proust effect, after the novelist whose madeleine dipped in tea brought back a whole childhood. The reason smell and memory are so tightly bound sits mostly in how the wiring is laid out.

Smell takes a shorter route to emotion and memory

Sight, sound and touch all pass through the thalamus, a relay station deep in the brain, before they reach the areas that handle memory and emotion. Smell is the exception, because signals from the nose travel to the olfactory bulb and from there connect almost directly to the amygdala, which drives emotional responses, and to the hippocampus and nearby structures that help lay down memories. With fewer stops between the scent and the feeling, the emotional reaction can land before your thinking brain has caught up.

The same layout explains a strange gap you have probably noticed in yourself. People are very good at telling whether they have smelled something before and surprisingly poor at naming it, a pattern researchers Harry Lawless and Trygg Engen described in 1977 as the tip of the nose state, after the familiar tip of the tongue feeling. The olfactory system's strongest links run to emotion and memory areas, with weaker links to language, so recognition arrives without a label attached.

You tend to notice how much work smell was doing only when it goes. People who lose their sense of smell through infection, head injury or ageing report effects well beyond flatter food, and a review by Ilona Croy, Steven Nordin and Thomas Hummel in 2014 found consistently higher rates of low mood in this group. A persistent, unexplained change in smell is also an early feature of some neurological conditions, so it is something to raise with your GP instead of waiting out.

Memories brought back by smell are older and more emotional

When researchers compare memories cued by smells with memories cued by words or pictures, the smell-cued ones come out differently. Rachel Herz, a psychologist at Brown University, found in a 2004 study that memories triggered by odours were rated as more emotional and gave a stronger sense of being brought back to the moment than memories triggered by the same items shown as pictures or sounds.

The age of the memories differs too. In a 2006 study, Johan Willander and Maria Larsson asked older adults to recall memories prompted by smells, words or pictures, and the smell-cued memories clustered in the first decade of life while the others peaked in adolescence and early adulthood. One reasonable explanation is that your strongest association with a given smell tends to form the first time you meet it, and for many everyday smells that happened in childhood.

These memories are often less worn as well, since the significant events you tell people about get reshaped a little with every retelling. A smell, on the other hand, can open something you haven't revisited in years, and that may be part of why it feels so vivid and so sudden.

The same shortcut leads to the memories you would rather avoid

Everything above applies just as much to painful memories. Smell is a common trigger for intrusive memories after a traumatic experience. Eric Vermetten and Douglas Bremner, writing on post-traumatic stress in 2003, described how smells such as smoke, fuel or a particular aftershave could set off strong reactions long after the event. Smell triggers can be harder to manage than others for a few reasons:

  • You can avoid a place or a photo far more easily than a smell in the air
  • The emotional response can start before you have consciously noticed the smell at all
  • The link to the original event is often obscure, so the reaction can feel as though it came from nowhere

Many people describe a sudden drop in mood or a surge of anxiety with no obvious cause, and when they trace it back it turns out to have followed a smell they never consciously registered. Nothing has gone wrong in that moment, since the same direct pathway is doing exactly what it always does.

Something you can try this week, if a shift in mood ever seems to come out of nowhere, is to pause and ask yourself what you can smell right now and what it might remind you of. A reaction you can attach to a cause is usually much easier to ride out than one that feels inexplicable, even though the feeling itself takes a while to settle.

Final thoughts

Smell reaches the parts of your brain that handle emotion and memory with fewer steps than any other sense, which is why a scent can return you to a childhood kitchen before you know what you are smelling. Most of the time that shortcut brings something pleasant. When it brings back something painful, recognising the mechanism is a useful first step, and the association itself can be worked on.

If smells, sounds or places are setting off reactions that feel out of proportion or come with no warning, that is a recognised pattern, and it is something you can work through with a psychologist. Our team works with trauma and acute stress at our St Kilda clinic, and online sessions are available if that suits you better. If you are in distress right now, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636, or 000 in an emergency.

trauma neuroscience psychology emotions